Single Hook vs Treble Hook Spinners for Trout
One of the most common questions I get at shows and in my inbox is whether a single hook spinner really catches as many trout as a treble. I understand why folks ask. Most spinners you pick up off a store pegboard come with a treble hook hanging off the back, so that is what a lot of us grew up throwing. But after years of fishing East Tennessee creeks and tailwaters, and hand tying every Magooster spinner myself, I put a single hook on as standard. Here is my honest take on single hooks vs trebles for trout, and how to choose the right one for the way you fish.
Why I Tie Magooster Spinners With Single Hooks
The short answer is that a good single hook hooks trout well and lets them go easier. When a trout hits a spinner, it usually comes at it hard and turns. A sharp single hook with a tied fly on it gets a solid bite on the corner of the mouth, and the fish stays pinned as long as you keep steady pressure.
The bigger reason is what happens after the fish is in the net. A treble has three points, and a trout that is thrashing around can end up hooked in two or three places at once, sometimes deep. With a single hook you usually have one clean hookset, which means less handling, less time out of the water, and a much better chance that fish swims off strong. If you want to keep a few stocked rainbows for supper, that is your call. But a lot of the trout we catch here in the Southeast are going back in the water, and I want my lures to make that easy.
There is also a practical side. Single hooks snag less on rocks, sticks, and laurel roots. On small mountain streams, where half your casts land next to something that wants to eat your lure, that saves a lot of retying and a lot of lost spinners.
Do Single Hooks Catch as Many Trout?
In my experience, you will hook just about as many fish. You may lose a few more on the jump, especially early on, but most of that comes down to technique. A few things help a lot:
- Keep your hook sharp. Check the point on your thumbnail every so often. If it slides instead of catching, touch it up or swap the spinner.
- Keep tension on the fish. Slack line is how single hooks come loose. Keep your rod tip up and keep reeling steady.
- Do not set too hard. With a spinner, the trout usually hooks itself on the retrieve. A firm sweep is plenty.
- Use the right size. The 1/8 oz is my pick for small creeks and skinny water, and the 1/4 oz handles bigger rivers and deeper runs. The right size keeps the spinner running in the strike zone, and a spinner in the strike zone gets eaten.
The tied fly on the hook matters too. It gives the trout something soft and buggy to grab, and it adds a little body that makes the spinner look like food instead of just flash. That is a big part of why patterns like the Tellico Nymph work so well on our home waters.
When a Treble Hook Still Makes Sense
I am not against trebles. There are times they make sense, and that is why I will tie trebles on request. If you are fishing a put and take stream where you plan to keep your limit, or you are taking a kid fishing for the first time and every hookup counts, a treble can help put a few more fish on the bank. Some anglers also just like them for big, fast water where trout tend to slap at a lure instead of eating it.
If that is you, just leave a note with your order or email me and I will tie your spinners with trebles. Same hand tied flies, same blades, just a different hook on the back.
Special Regulation Water and Catch and Release
Here in the Southeast, a lot of the best trout fishing is on special regulation water, like Delayed Harvest sections and trophy or catch and release streams. Many of those waters have rules about the kinds of hooks and lures you can use, and those rules are different from state to state and stream to stream. They can also change from year to year.
I am not going to try to quote the regulations for every river, because the only place to get them right is the source. Before you fish, check the current rules with your state wildlife agency, whether that is TWRA in Tennessee, the NC Wildlife Resources Commission, or Georgia DNR. Look at the specific stream you plan to fish, not just the general rules.
Tips for Releasing Trout Caught on Spinners
- Wet your hands before you touch a trout, and do not squeeze.
- Keep the fish in the water or right over it as much as you can.
- Use forceps or small pliers to back the hook out quickly.
- If a fish is hooked deep, cut the line close rather than digging around.
- Hold the trout facing upstream in gentle current until it kicks away on its own.
- If you want to go further, pinch the barb down with pliers. It makes unhooking even faster.
Built in Tennessee for the Way You Fish
Every Magooster spinner is USA made and hand tied by me here in Tennessee, one at a time. My dad made the original Magoosters, and the first trout I ever caught on a lure came on one of his 1/4 oz spinners. I still build them the same way: a good blade, a hand tied fly, and a single hook that treats the fish right.
If you fish smaller water, start with the 1/8 oz Magooster Trout Spinner. For bigger rivers and tailwaters, go with the 1/4 oz Magooster Trout Spinner. Both come in 12 colors, including the Tellico Nymph, and you can browse them all in the Trout Spinners collection.
Orders of $50 or more ship free anywhere in the US. If you are shopping for a trout angler this Christmas, place your order by December 15 so it gets there in time. Want trebles instead of singles? Just ask. Questions about what to throw on your home water? Email me at hunter@magoostertackle.com and I will be glad to help.
Tight lines,
Hunter McKinney
Magooster Tackle Co.